Planning on getting an epidural in the near future? Lay down and listen up
A recent study in The BMJ found that you’re more likely to deliver with less medical intervention if you lie down compared to sitting upright.
Research involving nearly 3,100 UK women who gave birth between 2010 and 2014 found that lying down was better for first-time moms who had low-dose epidurals. Those who had an epidural during the second stage of labor—when you’re fully dilated and ready to push—were more likely to have natural vaginal births without the need for suction or forceps. Women in the study who were lying down were either on their right or left side.
Of those in the study, 41.1 percent of women had spontaneous vaginal births when they were lying down. 35.2 percent had the same when they sat upright.
“The study provides evidence that first time mothers with an epidural who lie down on their side during the second stage of labour are more likely to have a spontaneous vaginal birth, with no apparent disadvantages in relation to short- or longer-term outcomes for mother or baby,” Peter Brocklehurst, a professor at the University of Birmingham, said in a statement.
“Like all clinical trials, the study does have its limitations and we can only speculate about the mechanism by which a lying-down position increases the chance of a spontaneous vaginal birth,” he added.
He said that the team is unsure if the findings would be the same in women who have given birth before.
“However, given the clear benefit of the lying-down position, perhaps all women who have an epidural should be offered the choice of adopting a lying-down position in the second stage until we know otherwise,” Brocklehurst added.
But that’s in the UK where about 30 percent of women get epidurals—things may be different in the U.S. where 70 percent of women opt for the spinal pain relief.
James Lozada, an anesthesiologist with the Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, said it’s hard to apply the findings to American women because things are different here.
“The women in this study were 85 percent white, thin and healthy,” Lozada told HelloFlo. “That’s a very different population of patients than almost anywhere in the U.S.”
He said that most women in the U.S. prefer lying down.
“There is neither a significant movement nor desire to deliver in varying positions,” Lozada noted. Therefore, the question of having a birth without interventions doesn’t really apply because American women typically stay in bed while delivering.
He pointed out some issues with the study. One issue was that the authors didn’t define what a low-dose epidural was, making it hard to evaluate, the analgesia used.
“The question of whether epidurals increase the rate of instrumental vaginal delivery is settled with large, randomized controlled trials from the U.S.,” Lozada added. “Epidurals using a low concentration of local anesthetics combined with opioids do not increase this risk, and is the best choice for most patients.”